Skip to content

CARITA GARDINER

What to Read When You're Avoiding School Work

Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Writing
  • “Why”…Wednesdays
  • GrammarLove
  • Contact/Subscribe
Menu

NetGalley Review of Till There Was You

Posted on September 29, 2023September 27, 2023 by caritagardiner
Screenshot 2023-09-26 at 9.48.52 PM

title: Till There Was You

author: Lindsay Hameroff

publisher: St. Martin's Griffin

publication date: February 20, 2024

pages: 320

peppers: 3 (on this scale)

warnings: dead parent (before the book), cut fingers/blood, burns

summary: New Yorker Lexi doesn't have time for dating while she's in culinary school pursuing her lifelong dream of becoming a chef, but when she goes out one night and meets singer Jake, her no-boys rule goes out the window during the whole weekend they spend together. After their brief affair, he goes to California to make his demo recording and hits it big...and busy. They don't talk with each other for a long time, until he appears back in town to record his second album.

tropes:

  • love at first sight
  • famous boyfriend
  • evil manager
  • life in the spotlight
  • she's his muse
  • great friends who tell the truth
  • visit home to the parents
  • dead mother, distant father
  • knew him before he was famous

what I liked:

  • they're true to each other
  • he's a genuinely good guy
  • great side characters
  • insider scenes in the restaurant's kitchen
  • descriptions of food that sounds yummy

what I didn’t like:

  • She thinks, "We're from different worlds" and "We just don't work together because I'm not a celebrity" too many times despite what he says and how he acts. I didn't buy it over and over.
  • The other woman seems too evil first then too good second. I didn't buy her transformation (maybe because it's off-page).

overall rating: 4 (of 5 stars)

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

WHAT I DO

I serve as a class dean and teach English to high schoolers at a boarding school in Connecticut. I’ve earned a Bachelor of Arts (Amherst College), an Education Master in Learning and Teaching (Harvard University Graduate School of Education), a Master of Arts in English (Bread Loaf School of English), and most recently a Master of Fine Arts in Creative Writing with a certificate in the online teaching of writing (Southern New Hampshire University).

As a writer, I hope to capture the complexity and joy of life in the New England boarding school world. On this site, I share what I know about trying to write fiction while deaning, teaching English, coaching, and doing the other tasks associated with helping to raise over six hundred other people’s children.

WHAT I CAN DO FOR YOU

Teach                    Tutor

Revise                   Edit

Entertain             Enlighten

Follow Me

  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Contact Me

  • cgardine@hotchkiss.org

Read my recent “Why” Wednesday Blog Posts

  • NetGalley Review of First and Forever
  • 384. Why The Imperfectionist
  • NetGalley Review of Burnout Summer
  • NetGally Review of How to Find a Guy in Five Weddings
  • 383. Why AI
© 2026 CARITA GARDINER | Powered by Minimalist Blog WordPress Theme